— Fall of sophomore year, high school, a suburb outside Albany, NY
New town. New kid. A month into a new school.
Migrating from inner city high school in Chicago to a suburban school in upstate NY was not like dancing a New Trier HS-inspired-“Mean Girls” salsa. Still, there were some slight shocks to my system. The classes were less competitive than Chicago’s IB curriculum. I was drowning in a sea of upper middle class, 99% white, Abercrombie and Fitch t-shirts. Football meant slightly more than monthly theater productions and music programs. Despite much contrast to the Chicago high school’s racial and ethnic makeup as well as the city’s diversity as a whole, the upstate NY charm was hard to avoid. The people were certainly very friendly and easy going…and oooh everyone had so much talent. Ah but high school is still…high school no matter where one moves.

Chicago's Lincoln Park H.S.
During my first semester at the new school, I befriended a girl in the junior class. I was a sophomore, but we had the same gym and chem lab periods. She thought I was “optimistic and friendly like a ray of sun.” “Perky” was her other description. Soon, she was curious about which boys I liked. Boys in a completely new school were bound to hold some interest for me, she said. One day in chem lab, as soon as the teacher let us loose to do some experiment, she turns to me with a hungry look.
“There must be guys you are starting to like here.”
I wasn’t really interested in anyone at the time. I missed Chicago terribly and was a bit overwhelmed with such homogeneity in the new town’s makeup to think about boys. Oh and a “little” event called 9/11 just happened.
“No one really. How about you?”
“Oooh but there has to be someone!”
She continued to ring my ears with the same line of questioning. Finally I thought I could get out of the tedious, monotonous conversation by saying a name, any guy’s name. Hmmm but WHOSE?
I started visually categorizing the guys I’ve met in four categories: 1) Taken; 2) The guy likes a girl / a girl likes the guy; 3) Singleness uncertain; and 4) Singleness absolute. Reasons? Easy: the first three categories are off limits. I would not want a girl to get wind of anything; gossip kills potential friendships fast. Caution is the New Girl’s best friend.

new school in upstate NY
Despite having been at the new school for only a month, it was obvious who liked whom in my classes and in the peripheral circles of my classmates. How about …… ? He must be single, and I’m fairly certain I haven’t heard of any girl who likes him. Hmmm and I don’t think this chem lab girl would know him. She’s a junior, and we are sophomores.
“If you don’t say his name, I’m going to start listing them for you!”
Mr. Swinton, the lab teacher, gave us a disapproving look as if to quiet us down. This has got to stop. I felt a flash of warm air hitting my cheeks. Oh no! I’m blushing.
“Actually there is someone. We barely talk though.”
“Ooooh. WHO?!”
“His initials are BH.”
Immediately, the boy sitting in front of me turned toward us slowly, careful to not incite attention. His ears perked up. Too late.
“What’s his full name?”
“Really?! Are we going there? That’s enough isn’t it?” Hmmm she’s not blinking at all. How can she do this! Does she not notice the guy sitting in front of me? Fine. Whatever. He probably doesn’t know BH.

“Okay. Okay.” I sighed. “It’s B—- H—–.”
The mysterious guy smiled. Oh no.
—– A week later
“Mr. Swinton? You know the guy who came in late last week? What’s his name? He left his notebook with my pile of books.”
“Oh I’m sorry. I don’t remember. Maybe try the Lost and Found?”
Think of something! Nothing. “That’s a great idea!”
Mr. Swinton starts roll call. The attendance sheet.
Pretending to ask a question at the board, I later sneaked a peek at the sheet. Everyone in my lab was accounted for. This means the stranger was making up a lab section. How am I to figure out who he is without revealing the reason?

SHS's chem lab in the 80s? 70s?
— 3 years later, senior prom
I finally figured out who the mysterious guy was. I danced with him at prom and suddenly recognized his half-smile. Maybe he did tell BH about my fake “crush.” It doesn’t matter now. My lack of interest in gossip was a turnoff to the chem lab girl’s crowd. I was secretly glad we stopped talking after my lie about having a crush. BH and I were not friends, and there was never any awkward tension.
—8 years later, one year post college
High school seems like such a long time ago, but I still remember the lie. To prevent gossip, I inadvertently caused one instead.